IFA 2014: Galaxy Note 4 and Edge will lose out to Apple’s iPhone 6 launch?

This week at IFA 2014, Samsung fired an impressive number of shots with a variety of products, two of which – the Galaxy Note 4 and Galaxy Note Edge – fall clearly where Apple is rumoured to be putting its new flagship iPhone, namely in the 5.5in space (Apple is expected to launch two phones, a handset with a 4.7in screen alongside a 5.5in phablet).

However, they've given Apple nearly a week to craft a response to these products and that is a long time for a firm that is known for creative marketing. I think Samsung may have made a tactical error. Let me explain.

Size does matter

We call phones over 5in phablets for good reason, they are as much tablet as they are phone and consumers generally see bigger things as better things. Having used phones in this class for some time I'm convinced once most folks in Apple's older demographic see the advantages in a big screen they'll think they died and went to heaven. Web pages are better laid out, text is far more legible, and both games and movies are far more fun to watch and play.

Going big is natural for Samsung but up till now Apple has been arguing that its smaller phone is more useful because it is easier to operate one-handed. This was actually a differentiating feature in Apple buyers' minds and bringing out a larger phone after Samsung will help validate the large size. They made this same move to an already established size with the iPad mini and that didn't go that well.

Galaxy Note 4 and Edge

The Galaxy Note Edge is the more interesting of these phones but the market has tried multiple display products before, and while they can pull a lot of ink in reviews users just haven't found the idea of multiple displays interesting. I think this is largely because there are few useful apps that use the second display and the idea of building an app for one expensive low volume phone isn't exciting developers at the moment.

Read more: Samsung Galaxy Note 4: Hands-on review

These guys need to make money and if Samsung wants this idea to fly they'll need to fund compelling apps. They've indicated these apps will be available in a few months when the phone launches, but I've heard this before and have little confidence they'll show up this time. Without the apps Apple can point to the screen and suggest that it is as useful as a third leg or second nose.

The Galaxy Note 4 is far more practical and likely will be far more popular, but it will be overshadowed by the Edge which will be seen as the more exclusive and unique product. People often buy new phones for status and Edge and Note 4 will be at cross purposes in this regard because the second edge screen looks much more cutting edge than the standard Note 4 display. One advantage the Note 4 has, though, is the VR headset option which initially will sell for around $200 (£120, or about $200/£120 higher than it should have been priced).

With this option you can better watch steamy movies or play VR games, although for the latter there has been a real issue finding a control system folks like to use with VR headsets (you can't see your hands and you won't be able to use the phone because it is floating before your eyes). I figure getting a controller people will be likely to use with the headset on will be an interesting problem for Samsung to solve.

Related: Should anyone be getting excited about Apple's iPhone 6?

How Apple beats Samsung – by channelling Steve Jobs

If Apple keeps to its normal script and focuses on keeping the message simple and on the elegance of the product they should win this exchange. Samsung's offerings, while compelling, aren't complete (they need the apps for the Edge and Note 4 VR) and they are conflicting (the VR feature works on one phone the edge display on the other) forcing customers to choose between their two flagship features.

Apple's only choice should be screen size and that is a matter of taste – you shouldn't have to give anything up other than size if you pick either of their new phones. Put differently, regardless of your choice between the Apple phones you'll feel good about your pick. But with Samsung if you choose the Edge and the apps don't show up, or you pick the VR feature and folks think you look stupid wearing the VR eye gear (it's loads more dorky than Google Glass), you'll be embarrassed, and who wants to buy a high-end phone with that kind of risk?

Read more: IFA 2014: Live news, pictures and analysis from Berlin

Had Samsung launched these products on the 8 September, Apple would have likely looked a day late and a dollar short, but in the next week folks will starting thinking through the Samsung offerings to see their shortcomings and Apple can rewrite their launch to accentuate those disadvantages. Jobs certainly would have done this. One of the reasons this is Tim Cook's most important launch event is because he now gets to demonstrate whether he learned how to fight this kind of fight from Steve Jobs. We'll see.