A Wikipedia contributor who uploaded several images of the portraits from the British National Portrait Gallery (NPG) in London has reportedly been slapped with a legal notice by the museum.
The user has been charged with downloading several high-resolution copyrighted images from the museum’s website, and subsequently making them available for the online encyclopaedia.
However, the Gallery notified that it had contacted Wikimedia Foundation way back in April about the matter and has had no positive response from the Foundation. So, it has decided to take legal action against the encyclopaedia’s volunteer updater Derrick Coetzee.
In its legal notice, the Gallery asked the updater to pull out the images and paintings from the website by 20 July, or else legal action will be taken against him.
The NPG’s lawyers Farrer & Co. wrote to Coetzee: “By posting the images to the Wikipedia website you are expressly authorising users to themselves make further copies of those images on their own screens and hard drives in the manner permitted by the GNU Free Documentation License”.
However, at first glance the case is apparently exerting pressure on Coetzee, but it’s not as clear cut as it seems to be, this is because of the different laws in the UK and the US. While the user resides in the UK, the NPG is based in the UK.
and join more than 1700 other followers.
Interesting legal case that will surely attract some attention, especially given that the BNPG is supported both by the government and by individuals, trusts and foundations. Since many of those portraits have been donated and apparently are in the public domain, it is likely to start a legal battle between the two parties and may set a nasty precedence.